Skip to content

Water Filter vs. Water Softener: Which One Do You Need?


Hard water won’t harm you, but it’s still a hassle. Your first guess might be to purchase a water filter, but is that the right choice? How do you know if a water filter or water softener is what your home needs? Don’t worry; we have all the information you need to make the right decision. Let’s discuss whether water filters or softeners are suitable for you.

  • Water filters and water softeners are not the same thing.
  • Water filters purify water by removing contaminates.
  • Water softeners remove calcium and magnesium from the water.
  • A water filter is good for your family’s health whereas a water softener is good for your home and its appliances.

Importance of water quality in the household

The importance of water quality in the household cannot be overstated. High-quality water is essential for maintaining the health and well-being of all family members, as it is used daily for drinking, cooking, bathing, and cleaning. Poor water quality can lead to various issues such as unpleasant tastes and odors, accumulation of harmful contaminants, and damage to household appliances and plumbing systems. Additionally, hard water can cause problems like scale buildup, dry skin, and hair, and reduced effectiveness of soaps and detergents. Ensuring that the water entering your home is clean, safe, and free from impurities is crucial in providing a healthy living environment for you and your family.

Water Filter vs. Water Softener: Not the Same Thing

All water filters and softeners have in common is they help with the annoyance of hard water. Many people may have issues deciding between the two because they’re unsure what filters and softeners do.
This blog post will help clear up the confusion. First, we’ll discuss water filters and explore softeners and their uses.

What Water Filters Do

Filters play a crucial role in improving your home’s water quality by removing various contaminants, including minerals that can cause hard water. When properly functioning, water filters can significantly enhance the taste and odor of your water. Some advanced water filters may also double as softeners, providing the combined benefits of both systems.

The primary function of a water filter is to eliminate harmful chemicals and impurities from your drinking water. These contaminants may include:

  • Industrial hormones and pesticides
  • Lead
  • Copper
  • Chromium
  • Chlorine
  • Chloramine
  • PFOS and PFOA (Perfluorooctane Sulfonate and Perfluorooctanoic Acid)
  • Particulates and particles (like sand)

It is essential to consider purchasing a water filter if you live in an area with high amounts of hard water or known contamination issues. Water filters are particularly beneficial for people residing in areas where water quality is a concern, as they can provide peace of mind by ensuring that your drinking water is safe and free from harmful substances.

Types of water filters

Water filters are available in various types, each designed to target specific contaminants and impurities in your water supply. Here’s a closer look at three common types of water filters:

Activated carbon filters

Reverse osmosis systems

Ultraviolet (UV) filters

Benefits of using a water filter

Using a water filter in your home provides numerous benefits, ranging from improved taste and odor to the removal of contaminants and potential health benefits. Here’s a closer look at these advantages:

  • Improved taste and odor
    One of the most noticeable benefits of using a water filter is the improvement in the taste and odor of your tap water. Unfiltered water can contain chlorine, organic compounds, and minerals that can give it an unpleasant taste or smell. By removing these contaminants, water filters can significantly improve the overall taste and odor of your drinking water, making it more enjoyable and encouraging you to stay hydrated.
  • Removal of contaminants
    Water filters are designed to remove a wide range of contaminants from your water supply, including heavy metals, chemicals, and microorganisms. Depending on the type of filter you choose, it can target specific impurities and help ensure that your water is free from harmful substances. By removing these contaminants, water filters not only improve the quality of your drinking water but also help protect your household appliances and plumbing system from the damaging effects of hard water and mineral buildup.
  • Health benefits
    Using a water filter can have significant health benefits for you and your family. Many contaminants found in unfiltered water, such as lead, arsenic, and bacteria, can pose serious health risks if consumed regularly. By effectively removing these harmful substances, water filters can help protect you from waterborne illnesses and long-term health issues associated with exposure to certain contaminants. In addition, filtered water can help promote overall health by encouraging proper hydration, supporting your immune system, and reducing the risk of gastrointestinal problems caused by contaminated water.

What Water Softeners Do

Here’s a handy way to distinguish water filters from softeners: filters disinfect and softeners clean. You cannot clear contaminants like lead, copper, or chlorine with a water softener.
A water softener gives you improved water quality by removing calcium and magnesium. Softeners greatly benefit your appliances and plumbing. Your water heater may warm water faster after you clean mineral build-up.

Softeners help remove calcium build-up, stopping clogging. You can expect extended functionality and longevity from appliances and piping that’s not blocked by calcium and magnesium deposits.

Hard water leaves stains on dishes and keeps your laundry from getting clean. It also causes dry skin and hair. You might notice cleaner clothes and better-hydrated skin and hair once you start using water softeners.

Types of water softeners

There are several types of water softeners available on the market, each utilizing different mechanisms to address hard water issues. Here’s an overview of the most common types:

Ion-exchange systems

Salt-free water softeners

Magnetic water softeners

Benefits of using a water softener

Installing a water softener in your home can offer a variety of benefits, including the prevention of scale buildup, improved appliance efficiency, and softer skin and hair. Let’s take a closer look at these advantages:

  • Prevention of scale buildup
    One of the primary benefits of using a water softener is its ability to prevent scale buildup in your pipes and appliances. Hard water contains high levels of minerals, such as calcium and magnesium, which can accumulate on your plumbing fixtures and lead to reduced water flow and clogs. By softening the water, a water softener helps prevent these issues, extending the life of your plumbing system and reducing the need for costly repairs.
  • Improved appliance efficiency

    Water-using appliances, such as dishwashers, washing machines, and water heaters, can become less efficient over time due to the buildup of mineral deposits from hard water. A water softener helps reduce the mineral content in your water supply, which can improve the efficiency of these appliances and help them last longer. In addition, softened water can lead to better soap and detergent performance, resulting in cleaner dishes, laundry, and surfaces throughout your home.

  • Softer skin and hair
    Using a water softener can also have noticeable benefits for your skin and hair. Hard water can cause skin irritation and dryness, as well as make your hair feel rough and unmanageable. Softened water is gentler on your skin and hair, helping to reduce irritation, dryness, and damage. By installing a water softener, you may find that your skin feels smoother and more hydrated, while your hair becomes softer and easier to style.
Our certified plumbers install new water heaters in both homes and businesses here in Chicago and Northwest Indiana.

Water Softener vs. Whole House Filter: Which One Should You Get?

A water softener is an ideal choice if you are concerned about the effects of hard water on your laundry, dishes, and skin. Hard water can cause your clothes to become stiff, and dishware to develop spots and stains, while also contributing to dry skin and hair. By installing a water softener, you can address these issues by removing the minerals responsible for water hardness, resulting in softer water that is gentler on your belongings and your body.

On the other hand, water filters are the best option if you have valid concerns about the health and safety of your drinking water. Water filters remove harmful contaminants, ensuring that you and your family have access to clean, safe water for drinking and cooking.

As mentioned earlier, some water filters are designed to soften water in addition to filtering out contaminants. If you live in an area where both hard water and water contamination are significant concerns, it may be worth considering a dual water softening and filtration system. These systems combine the benefits of both water softeners and filters, providing comprehensive protection against the negative effects of hard water and the potential health risks posed by waterborne contaminants. By investing in a dual system, you can ensure that your household water supply is not only safe to drink but also gentle on your skin, clothes, and appliances.

Water Filtration System vs. Water Softener: Conclusion

Both water filters and softeners are effective in addressing hard water issues. However, water filters take it a step further by also eliminating various other contaminants and impurities from your water supply. The choice between a water filter and a softener largely depends on your specific household needs and your location’s water quality.

To make an informed decision, it’s essential to understand the differences between a water filter and a water softener. While a water softener is a specific type of filter designed to address hard water by removing minerals like calcium and magnesium, not all filters have softening capabilities. Water filters, on the other hand, are designed to remove a broad range of contaminants, such as chemicals, heavy metals, and particulate matter. Some advanced water filters may also function as softeners, providing comprehensive protection against both hard water and other water quality issues.

When considering whether to purchase a water filter or a softener, you should assess your household’s unique needs and the water quality in your location. If hard water is the primary concern, a water softener may be sufficient. However, if you’re worried about the presence of harmful contaminants in your water supply, a water filter may be a more appropriate choice. For households dealing with both hard water and water contamination issues, a dual-function system that combines the benefits of water softening and filtration may be the best solution.

Frequently Asked Questions

Knowing what to ask about water softeners can be challenging. We have you covered with this handy FAQ section.

How Does a Water Softener Work?

How Do You Maintain a Water Softener?

How Long Does a Water Softener Last?

How to Filter Water at Home?

What is the difference between a salt-based and salt-free water softener?

Can water filters remove bacteria and viruses?

How often should I change my water filter cartridge?

How much does it cost to install a water softener or water filter system

How King Can Help

King Heating, Cooling & Plumbing has over 50 years of experience with HVAC and plumbing issues. You can trust our team to quickly and competently install your water filter. Contact us when ready to supply your home with safe, clean drinking water. We’ll be out as soon as possible to install your new whole-home water filtration system.